2. If
one holds a 2nd dan in
one style but 1st dan
level in 2 other styles,
are they a 2nd degree
black belt or a 4th? Is
it appropriate to wear a
belt with 4 stripes on
one side and 2 stripes
on the other with that
style on the belt? -
Vicki
... Different
degrees obtained in
different arts do not
add up to a higher dan grade.
Although there is no
question that further
levels of training
expands the knowledge
and experience of the
martial artist, it
doesn't necessarily mean
that within the
curriculum of any one
style that they have
progressed.
... The
black belt holder knows
better than others the
origins, teachers, and
examiners that granted
their degree status. It
is a redundancy and a
great expression of
self-indulgence to try
to show others more
stripes in the belt than
the ones really
deserved. Perhaps, your
question reflects an
observation of someone
that it is doing it, or
simply a genuine doubt,
however it should be
made clear that in the
study of the martial
arts, no matter what
traditions they come
from, the dan system is
not contemplated as a
reward, nor as an
accumulation or
expression of status and
self-importance.
... The
appropriate way to deal
with the question is to
wear the belt degree
from each discipline
within the respective
class environment or
activity. If there is
more than one art in
question then simply
change your belt when
the occasion requires
it. A more practical way
is to wear a black belt
without stripes at all
so it can be worn in all
of the practiced arts.
That's what we
do. |